Calissa Hamptons Menu (Updated October 2025)

Welcome to Calissa Hamptons, your quintessential Greek dining destination tucked away at 1020 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY. With a delightful combination of traditional Mediterranean flavors and a touch of Hamptons elegance, Calissa radiates warmth and charm, making it perfect for family gatherings, celebrations, or simply a memorable night out.

As you explore the menu, you’ll be drawn in by offerings like the Mediterranean Dorade, grilled to perfection and enhanced by a sprinkle of Greek sea salt and a drizzle of olive oil — a true taste of the Aegean. The grill also showcases succulent Lamb Chops, either four or eight pieces, grilled simply yet profoundly flavorsome. Don’t miss the Lobster Pasta, a rich delight that embodies the best of coastal cuisine.

The sides are equally inviting, featuring sautéed Horta greens and roasted lemon potatoes that elevate any meal to new heights. Notably, the ambiance strikes a remarkable balance; it’s both cozy and refined. Whether it's your first visit or you’re returning, each dish served is a celebration of the quality ingredients and the meticulous preparation behind them. As many reviews indicate, a trip to Calissa is not just about food; it’s about an experience that lingers well beyond the last bite.

Extra Menu Picks